- cross-posted to:
- privacy@programming.dev
- cross-posted to:
- privacy@programming.dev
Not gonna lie, I’d like to use this geotag a bunch of photos that I dont have location tagged to it.
NO CITIZEN BENEFIT! SURVEILLANCE USE ONLY!
Is it just reading metadata and pretending it’s doing something impressive?
It’s doing what the Geo Guesser-like people do.
Like ‘this kind of rock formation only appears in Eastern Europe, the wheel you see in the lower left of the screen has Cyrillic writing and if you look in eastern Europe there is one mountain formation that looks like the picture when viewed from a specific angle and so they had to be within this 50m circle’.
Eh, kind of both.
When researchers peeked into which areas of the image were being used, it showed that the tiny camera watermark from the Google Streetview car was being used by the model a lot.
That is, the recognition system had learned all the routes every Google Street view car had taken, and was using that in its recognition process.
Not all images have this watermark though, so in the cases the watermark didn’t exist it then resorts to more traditional geoguessr tactics.
This is the kind of thing that machine learning is very very good at. Its never going to be perfect but its definitely gonna outperform humans.
In addition, any organization that’s using this at scale will also have human experts to handle the edge cases and to validate the system’s findings.
We can’t copy the human expert without years of training, but copying a program/computer system is only a few terminal commands. The ability to do this kind of thing at scale is entirely new.
It’s not hard. I once saw a random “what is this thing” photo from a bad angle. But it included a store in the background. Only two stores in North America with that name, though Google map search tried to be helpful and return a bunch of other results. Easy enough to check both.
Even with the extra street view angles I couldn’t figure out what the thing was though :(
Would be funny if it’s just an API call to OpenAI in the backend
Funnier if it just funneled all requests to the GeoGuessr dude.
“Do you funnel all requests to the GeoGuessr dude?”
“No.”
“Be a lot cooler if you did.”
human-as-a-service
Way to go rebranding ‘employment.’







